• home
  • articles
  • editorial
idea mater

Travels, books and bad journalism

1/10/2013

0 Comments

 
Picture
Some months ago my attention was drawn to a post in the BBC News:  for the first time would be exhibited in New Delhi a rare book from a 16th-century Italian traveller, Ludovico di Varthema, who compiled adventures and observations in his Itinerario de Ludovico de Varthema Bolognese. According to the BBC post, this was the "first 'travel best-seller' on India, translated to more than 50 languages", enriched with "detailed drawings" which were an essential part of its success.

Picture
Taking a closer look at the drawings, I noticed something that seemed quite intriguing: they had legends in XVI century Portuguese! Being Varthema Italian and the book's first print made in Italian (it was firstly edited in Rome, in 1510)  why would the drawings' legends be in Portuguese and not in Italian or even Latin?

Another article from the Indian Express seemed to corroborate part of the BBC information - the book was being displayed at “Voyages to India of Ludovico de Varthema”. Nevertheless, the same article added that the exhibition comprised "excerpts of Varthema’s book with illustrations", a work translated to about 20 languages(!). This was confusing: did the exhibition consist of the real book or excerpts of it? 

Picture
Messy! 
Only two things seemed certain: Varthema's story and drawings looked nice AND both my sources were a good example of bad journalism. But still, why legends in Portuguese?  Researching the Wikipedia article on Varthema, which corroborates the drawings and 50 languages facts (both very unreliable information), I read that he joined the Portuguese garrison in 1506. So, maybe the drawings were made under Portuguese commission, later included in the book?  

Picture
As part of my interest for Gothic art, I've been reading about D. Manuel I, who reigned Portugal in the highlight of our over-seas explorations. He sponsored the Jerónimos monastery  and other associated pieces of art, namely the Belém monstrance - to which I briefly referred to in a previous post. This unique piece of jewellery has a fascinating story, but for now the relevant part is that it was made with gold extorted from Kilwah, current Tanzania - a place visited by Varthema.
So, having in one hand D. Manuel I, Kilwah, gold and mysterious Portuguese legends in beautiful drawings, and on the other misleading internet information, I decided to drink from the source and got myself a nice 1863 British edition of Varthema's book. And here we go, trivia style:

Picture
7 essential notes on Ludovico di Varthema
1. Ludovico di Varthema (c. 1470-1517) was a Bolognese who traveled in the middle-East, Asia and East-Africa from the end of 1502 to 1508;
2. He was driven by the avidity for knowledge and exciting experiences, wishing to share his memories with the world;
3. He learned colloquial Arab in a few months and assumed the fake Muslim identity of Yunus (Jonah), what allowed him, for instance, to travel with the Mamlukes and visit the forbidden Mecca, in May 1503. He became the first known non-Muslim to accomplish this;

Picture
4. He wandered extensively from Egypt to Syria, Persia to India, Indonesia and from there to East Africa;
5. In India he joined the Portuguese garrison, later knighted by the Vice-roy Francisco de Almeida for his services for the Portuguese crown. 
6. Returning to Europe via Cape of Good Hope, Azores and Lisbon, in an italian vessel, he was received by King D. Manuel I, who enjoyed listening to his stories, reaffirming his knighthood. 
7. He expressed the wish to travel further, this time to the "north", but apparently this didn't materialise.

Picture
And the legends in the drawings? Well, simple - there are none: no drawings in Varthema's book! That's because the drawings originally belonged to a group of documents named ‘Portuguese Codice’, part of Cardinal Casanata's (1620 -1698)  library - more about the subject here and here. The authorship of the drawings in unknown: it's not impossible Varthema did them, but highly unlikely! 


Next: Varthema's trip and his eye-witness accounts on widows on fire and 16th-century swingers!

Text by Rafael Fraga © 2013
Photos by Rafael Fraga and WikiCommons.

Share |
Please share your opinion, insights and critics with us, commenting bellow. We'd love to hear from you! Thanks!
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Picture
    idea mater is a series of articles, ideas and reflections written and compiled by Rafael Fraga and Edmundo Rodrigues. Topics such as history, science, art or life-style are presented with a hint of personal opinion.

    Hot posts:
    I do not drink. So what?
    Ravel and Barnes: art and corruption
    Andon cord of life + 2 football stories
    Power of time: Lapse photography
    Travels, books and bad journalism
    Camera assassin: the smartphone
    Ladies and a virgin in the Red Light
    Subscribe idea mater HERE and get regular notifications

    RSS Feed


    Archives

    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    September 2013
    May 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013

    Categories

    All
    2014
    Alchemy
    Amsterdam
    Architecture
    Artifacts
    Australia Road Trip
    Books
    Cell
    City Life
    Earth
    History
    Nasa
    Opinion
    Phone
    Photography
    Portugal
    Revolution
    Science
    Symbols
    Technology
    Travels

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.